Federalism and subsidiarity in the system of internal government relations: certain theoretical and practical aspects of their interaction (using the example of the Russian Federation)

Pimenova, Oksana

Home>Issue 4>Federalism and subsidiarity in the system of internal government relations: certain theoretical and practical aspects of their interaction (using the example of the Russian Federation)

Table of contents

Annotation Estimate Publication content

References Comments

Federalism and subsidiarity in the system of internal government relations: certain theoretical and practical aspects of their interaction (using the example of the Russian Federation)

Annotation

PII

S1026-94520000616-5-1

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Oksana Pimenova Send message

Edition

Issue 4

Pages

5-16

Abstract

Federalism and subsidiarity may be used in any multi-level political system where leadership belongs either to the federal or regional government, or both. In such systems neither level of government is superior to the other a priori; thus, subsidiarity and federalism complement each other maintaining the balance of powers and consequently the stability of a system in general. Within federative systems, the subsidiarity principle is very close to the concept of public and legal institute of joint competence of the federation and its constituent entities. It's these very countries - federative states - where federal government bodies should be exercising regulating functions in the area of joint competence on the basis of the subsidiarity principle, as the main idea of federalism, as well as that of subsidiarity, is the following: don't take over what others can do for themselves!

Keywords

federalism, federative system, subsidiarity, sovereignty, joint competence, regulating functions, constituent entities of the Russian Federation, the Council of Federation, federal legislative process

Date of publication

01.04.2017

Number of purchasers

Views

1105

Readers community rating

0.0 (0 votes)

Cite Download pdf Download JATS

GOST	Pimenova O. Federalism and subsidiarity in the system of internal government relations: certain theoretical and practical aspects of their interaction (using the example of the Russian Federation) // Gosudarstvo i pravo. – 2017. – Issue 4 C. 5-16 .
MLA	Pimenova, Oksana "Federalism and subsidiarity in the system of internal government relations: certain theoretical and practical aspects of their interaction (using the example of the Russian Federation)." Gosudarstvo i pravo. 4 (2017).:5-16.
APA	Pimenova O. (2017). Federalism and subsidiarity in the system of internal government relations: certain theoretical and practical aspects of their interaction (using the example of the Russian Federation). Gosudarstvo i pravo. no. 4, pp.5-16

References

Additional sources and materials

1. Hirsh G. Le principe de subsidiarity dans une perspective comparatiste//In: Delperee F., ed. Le principe de subsidiarity. Bruxelles, 2002. P. 57. 
 
 2. Brouillet E. Canadian federalism and the principle of subsidiarity: should we open pandora's box?//Supreme Court Law Review. 2011. 54 S.C.L.R. (2d). P. 602. 
 
 3. Demirci B. The principle of subsidiarity in the European Union context: a thesis submitted to the graduate school of social sciences of Middle East Technical University. September, 2003. R. 26. 
 
 4. Benoist de A. The First Federalist: Johannes Althusius. Paris, 2000. P. 33. 
 
 5. Hueglin T. O. Federalism, subsidiarity and the European tradition: some clarifications. Telos, 1994. P. 43. 
 
 6. Tadevosyan Eh. V. Problemy rossijskogo federalizma//Sots. issledovaniya. 2001. № 7. S. 148 
 
 7. Vagizov R. G. Federalizm i prava narodov//Kazanskij federalist. 2004. № 3 (11). S. 60 
 
 8. Kiseleva A.V., Nesterenko A. V. Teoriya federalizma. M., 2002. S. 126, 127; 
 
 9. Tehps D. S.-M. Rossijskij federalizm: problemy teorii i konstitutsionno-pravovogo regulirovaniya. Avtoref. diss.... doktora yurid. nauk. SPb., 2005. S. 26, 27. 
 
 10. Bandieri L. M. Carl Schmitt and Federalism. 2002. P. 48. 
 
 11. Watts R. L. Comparing Federal Systems. Montreal and Kingston, 1999; 
 
 12. King P. T. Federalism and federation. London, 1982; 
 
 13. Hueglin Th.O. and Fenna A. Comparative federalism: a systematic inquiry. Toronto, 2006. 
 
 14. Duchacek I. D. Comparative federalism. New York, 1970. P. 234-244; 
 
 15. Elazar D. J. Exploring federalism. Tuscaloosa, 1987. P. 166-168. 
 
 16. King L. Cities, subsidiarity and federalism. Spring, 2012. R. 2. 
 
 17. Kisker G. The West German Federal Constitutional Court as guardian of the federal system//Publius. Vol. 19. 1999. N 4. P. 35-52. 
 
 18. Osaghae E. A. Reassessment of federalism as a degree of decentralization//Ibid. Vol. 20. 1990. N 1. P. 83-98. 
 
 19. Lejeune Y. Participation of subnational units in foreign policy of the federation//In: Blindenbacher R. and Koller A. Federalism in a changing world: learning from each other. Montreal and Kingston, 2003. P. 97-114. 
 
 20. Oxford dictionaries online//http://oxforddictionaries.com 
 
 21. Theret V. Du principe f6d6ral a une typologie des f6d6rations: quelques propositions//In: Gaudreault-Desbiens & Gelinas (eds). Le f6d6ralisme dans tous ses etats: gouvernance, identity et mythodologie (2005). P. 128. Tsit. po: Brouillet E. Op. cit. R. 608. 
 
 22. Delcamp A. Principe de subsidiarity et decentralisation//Revue frangaise de droit constitutionnel. 1993. R. 609. 
 
 23. Krasikov D. V. Yurisdiktsiya Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka: printsip subsidiarnosti. Diss.... kand. yurid. nauk. M., 2003. S. 15. 
 
 24. V poiskakh grazhdanskogo obschestva. Ser. "Nauchnye doklady"/Otv. red. K. V. Zavershinskij. V. Novgorod, 2008. S. 94. 
 
 25. Ehntin L. M. Pravo Evropejskogo Soyuza. Novyj ehtap ehvolyutsii: 2009-2017 gody. M., 2009. S. 59. 
 
 26. Mescheryakova O. M. Suverenitet gosudarstv -chlenov Evropejskogo Soyuza i mekhanizmy ego zaschity. M., 2008. S. 6-8. 
 
 27. Ampleeva A. A. Subsidiarnost' i demokratiya. Vvedenie v temu. M., 1996. S. 6. 
 
 28. Hogg P. W. Subsidiarity and the division of powers in Canada (1993). R. 345. 
 
 29. Golub J. Sovereignty and Subsidiarity in EU Environmental Policy//Political Studies. 1996. XLIV. P. 702. 
 
 30. Held D. Democracy and the Global order. Cambridge, 1995. 
 
 31. Breton A., Cassone A., Fraschini A. Decentralization and subsidiarity: toward a theoretical reconciliation (1998). R. 21. 
 
 32. Friesen M. Subsidiarity and federalism: an old concept with contemporary relevance for political society//Federal Governance: A Graduate Journal of Theory and Politics (2003). P. 10. 
 
 33. Kuhnhardt L. Federalism and subsidiarity//Telos. NY, 1992. N 91. P. 82. 
 
 34. Requejo F. Federalism and national groups//International Social Science Journal. 2001. N 53 (167). R. 43. 
 
 35. Bednar J. Subsidiarity and robustness: building the adaptive efficiency of federal systems//In: Fleming J., Levy J. (eds.). NOMOS: American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy. N.Y., 2014. R. 1. 
 
 36. Toth A. G. Is subsidiarity justiciable? Oxford, 1994. P. 40. 
 
 37. Shakhraj S. M. Konstitutsionnoe pravosudie v sisteme rossijskogo federalizma. M., 2001. S. 42. 
 
 38. Zubrilina A. O. Subsidiarnost' v kontekste federalistskoj teorii//Filosofiya prava. 2015. № 5 (72). S. 91-96. 
 
 39. Gaganova N. A. Printsip subsidiarnosti v konstitutsionnom prave. Avtoref. diss.. kand. yurid. nauk. M., 2006. S. 16. 
 
 40. Vetrov D. M. Istochniki konstitutsionnogo prava Rossijskoj Federatsii v sisteme federativnykh otnoshenij. Avtoref. diss.... kand. yurid. nauk. Chelyabinsk, 2003. S. 57. 
 
 41. Anisimova N. V. Printsip subsidiarnosti v evropejskom prave. Diss.. kand. yurid. nauk. M., 2005. S. 65. 
 
 42. Tikhomirov Yu. A. Tsentralizatsiya i detsentralizatsiya: dinamika sootnosheniya//Zhurnal ross. prava. 2007. № 2. S. 99-105. 
 
 43. Konstitutsionnoe zakonodatel'stvo Rossii/Pod red. Yu. A. Tikhomirova. M., 1999. S. 12. 
 
 44. Umnova I. A. Konstitutsionnye osnovy sovremennogo rossijskogo federalizma. M., 1998. S. 220, 221. 
 
 45. Ehntin L. M. Ukaz. soch. S. 59. V ehtoj svyazi nel'zya soglasit'sya s temi avtorami, kotorye predlagayut subsidiarnost' rassmatrivat' kak "printsip razgranicheniya kompetentsii" (sm.: Gligich-Zolotareva M. V. Konstitutsionno-pravovye osnovy rossijskogo federalizma: problemy teorii, metodologii i praktiki. Avtoref. diss.... doktora yurid. nauk. Tyumen', 2009. S. 11) 
 
 46. Aroyan A. S. Subsidiarnost' kak kontseptual'naya osnova ehffektivnogo vzaimodejstviya gosudarstva, mestnogo samoupravleniya i grazhdanskogo obschestva. Diss.... kand. polit. nauk. Ro-stov-n/D., 2010. S. 19, 20 
 
 47. Chirkin V. E. Federalizm: teoriya, instituty, otnosheniya (Cravnitel'no-pravovoe issledovanie). M., 2001. S. 162. 
 
 48. Bermann G. A. Taking subsidiarity seriously: federalism in the European Community and the United States//Columbia Law Review. 1994. Vol. 94. N 2. R. 331-456; 
 
 49. Schutze R. From dual to cooperative federalism. Oxford, 2009; 
 
 50. Schutze R. Subsidiarity after Lisbon: reinforcing the safeguards of federalism?//Cambridge Law Journal. Vol. 68. 2009. N 3. R. 525-536. 
 
 51. Fadeeva T. M. Model' Evropejskogo Soyuza i problemy sovremennogo federalizma. M., 2005. S. 73. 
 
 52. Anikin S. B. Administrativno-pravovoe regulirovanie predmetov sovmestnogo vedeniya i polnomochij Rossijskoj Federatsii i sub'ektov Rossii. Avtoref. diss.... doktora yurid. nauk. Saratov, 2011. S. 21. 
 
 53. Pimenova O. I. Subsidiarnost' kak printsip realizatsii sovmestnykh zakonodatel'nykh polnomochij: opyt Evropejskogo Soyuza i perspektivy ego adaptatsii v rossijskoj sisteme razgranicheniya polnomochij po predmetam sovmestnogo vedeniya. M., 2015. S. 86-138. 
 
 54. Sidzhanski D. Federalistskoe buduschee Evropy: ot Evropejskogo Soobschestva do Evropejskogo Soyuza. M., 1998. S. 241. 
 
 55. Evropejskij Soyuz. Osnovopolagayuschie akty v redaktsii Lissabonskogo dogovora s kommentariyami/Avt. komment.: S. Yu. Kashkin, A. O. Chetverikov; per. A. O. Chetverikov. M., 2008. S. 603. 
 
 56. Lenaerts K. The Principle of Subsidiarity and the Environment in the European Union: Keeping the Balance of Federalism//Fordham International Law Journal. Vol. 17. Issue 4. 1993. R. 875. 
 
 57. Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1999. № 42. St. 5005. 
 
 58. Tikhomirov Yu.A. Teoriya kompetentsii // Zhurnal ross. prava. 2000. № 10 // http:// www.consultant.ru 
 
 59. O sostoyanii zakonodatel'stva Rossijskoj Federatsii. Doklad Soveta Federatsii Federal'nogo Sobraniya Rossijskoj Federatsii 2010 goda. M., 2011. S. 50. 
 
 60. Knyaginin K. N. Zakonodatel'stvo sub'ektov Rossijskoj Federatsii kak indikator rossijskoj federativnoj sistemy//Sovremennye problemy konstitutsionnogo i munitsipal'nogo stroitel'stva: opyt Rossii i zarubezhnykh stran. Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf. Yuridicheskij fakul'tet MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova. Moskva, 10-13 marta 2010 goda/Otv. red. S. A. Avak'yan. M., 2010. S. 248-254. 
 
 61. Gligich-Zolotareva M. V. Zakonodatel'naya baza federativnykh otnoshenij: perspektivy sovershenstvovaniya//Zhurnal ross. prava. 2002. № 7. S. 50, 51; 
 
 62. Salikov M. S. Konstitutsionnyj Federalizm Rossii: opyt desyatiletnego razvitiya//Federalizm. 2003. № 3. S. 13; 
 
 63. Nesmeyanova S.Eh. K voprosu o "sovmestnom vedenii"//Sovremennye problemy konstitutsionnogo i munitsipal'nogo stroitel'stva: opyt Rossii i zarubezhnykh stran. Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf. Yuridicheskij fakul'tet MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova. Moskva, 10-13 marta 2010 goda/Otv. red. S. A. Avak'yan. S. 220, 222. 
 
 64. Federal'nyj zakon "O vnesenii izmenenij v otdel'nye zakonodatel'nye akty Rossijskoj Federatsii v svyazi s sovershenstvovaniem razgranicheniya polnomochij" ot 31 dekabrya 2005 g.//Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2006. № 1. St. 10. 
 
 65. Stepanova V.M. O praktike "operezhayuschego" pravotvorchestva sub'ektov Rossijskoj Federatsii po predmetam sovmestnogo vedeniya // Zakonodatel'stvo i ehkonomika. 2008. № 6 // http:// consultant.ru 
 
 66. Khabrieva T. Ya. Razgranichenie zakonodatel'noj kompetentsii Rossijskoj Federatsii i ee sub'ektov//Sootnoshenie zakonodatel'stva Rossijskoj Federatsii i zakonodatel'stva sub'ektov Rossijskoj Federatsii/Avt. koll.: Eh.P. Andryukhina, A.I. Abramova, S.A. Bogolyubov i dr.; red. koll.: T.Ya. Khabrieva (otv. red.) i dr. M., 2003. S. 124. 
 
 67. postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF "Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti ryada polozhenij Ustava -Osnovnogo zakona Chitinskoj oblasti" ot 1 fevralya 1996 g.//Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1996. № 7. St. 700. 
 
 68. postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenij statej 18 i 20 Zakona Rossijskoj Federatsii "Ob osnovakh nalogovoj sistemy v Rossijskoj Federatsii"» ot 21 marta 1997 g.//Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1997. № 13. St. 1602. 
 
 69. postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenij Zakona Ivanovskoj oblasti "O munitsipal'noj sluzhbe Ivanovskoj oblasti" v svyazi s zaprosom Zakonodatel'nogo sobraniya Ivanovskoj oblasti» ot 15 dekabrya 2003 g.//Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2003. № 52. St. 5101. 
 
 70. punkt 4 st. 26.1, p. 7 st. 26.3 Federal'nogo zakona "Ob obschikh printsipakh organizatsii zakonodatel'nykh (predstavitel'nykh) i ispolnitel'nykh organov gosudarstvennoj vlasti sub'ektov Rossijskoj Federatsii" ot 6 oktyabrya 1999 g. // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1999. № 42. St. 5005; st. 31 Byudzhetnogo kodeksa RF // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 1998. № 31. St. 3823. 
 
 71. Kontseptsiya dolgosrochnogo sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskogo razvitiya Rossijskoj Federatsii na period do 2020 goda, utverzhdennaya Rasporyazheniem Pravitel'stva RF ot 17 noyabrya 2008 g. № 1662-r//Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 2008. № 47. St. 5489. 
 
 72. Yusubov Eh. S. Sub'ekt Rossijskoj Federatsii kak institut razvitiya//Sovremennye problemy konstitutsionnogo i munitsipal'nogo stroitel'stva: opyt Rossii i zarubezhnykh stran. Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf. Yuridicheskij fakul'tet MGU im. M. V. Lomonosova. Moskva, 10-13 marta 2010 goda/Otv. red. S. A. Avak'yan. S. 258. 
 
 73. postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF "Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti Zemel'nogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosom Murmanskoj oblastnoj Dumy" ot 23 aprelya 2004 g.//Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF. 2004. № 4. 
 
 74. postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF "Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti Lesnogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federatsii" ot 9 yanvarya 1998 g.//Tam zhe. 1998. № 2. 
 
 75. Konyukhova I., Vekshin A. Sovmestno s regionami: kak obespechit' bol'shee vzaimodejstvie palat Federal'nogo Sobraniya s sub'ektami RF v protsesse zakonodatel'noj deyatel'nosti//Rossijskaya Federatsiya segodnya. 2005. № 12. S. 73; 
 
 76. Ishekov K.A., Tyurin P.Yu., Cherkasov K.V. Kommentarij k Federal'nomu zakonu ot 6 oktyabrya 1999 goda № 184-FZ "Ob obschikh printsipakh organizatsii zakonodatel'nykh (predstavitel'nykh) i ispolnitel'nykh organov gosudarstvennoj vlasti sub'ektov Rossijskoj Federatsii". M., 2006. 
 
 77. Tokvil' A. Demokratiya v Amerike/Per. s fr.; predisl. G. Dzh. Laski. M., 1992//http://www.gumer.info/ 
 
 78. Delcamp A. Principe de subsidiarity et decentralisation//Revue frangaise de droit constitutionnel. 1993. R. 621. 
 
 79. Leksin I. V. Territorial'noe ustrojstvo Rossii: konstitutsionno-pravovye problemy. M., 2014. S. 31. 
 
 80. Elazar D. The American Partnership: Intergovernmental Cooperation in the Nineteenth Century United States. Chicago, 1967. P. 14-27. 
 
 81. Vause G. W. The subsidiarity principle in European Union Law//American Federalism. 2008. N 34. P. 67.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review

Translate

References

Additional sources and materials

Comments

Via social network